• ABOUT US
    • History
    • Our Team
    • Advertising
    • Subscription
  • CONTACT US
Georgia Today
No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business & Economy
  • Social & Society
  • Sports
  • Culture
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business & Economy
  • Social & Society
  • Sports
  • Culture
No Result
View All Result
Georgia Today
No Result
View All Result

The Fragile South Caucasus

by Georgia Today
April 6, 2023
in Analysis, Editor's Pick, International, Newspaper, Politics
Reading Time: 3 mins read
Image source: aze.media

Image source: aze.media

The South Caucasus is a fragile region security-wise. Cross-border insecurity and various sorts of extremism have proved from time to time to be a region-wide problem. In connection with the geopolitical fragility of the region, other interesting developments are taking place which mean that the South Caucasus has entered a different era amid the war in Ukraine, US-China competition, and growing cooperation between Iran and Russia.

The construction of an order of exclusion in the South Caucasus, based on a loose understanding among regional powers, means that the balance of power concept has made its way back. Realism has prevailed against the liberal world order, which seems increasingly threatened by growing external opposition, internal troubles, and declining authority/prestige (the troubles a chaotic US withdrawal from Afghanistan left the country in is a good example). For Iran, Russia, Turkey, and China, the balance of power idea is a concept which resonates well with each of these states’ historical experiences. Each has always positioned itself as a civilization state as opposed to the Western concept of nation-states. The four have similar geographic dilemmas which, over the course of the past several centuries, informed their behavior and still continue to haunt the countries’ political classes. Encirclement by enemies is a constant feature in the nationalist discourses. Balance of power for Iran, Russia, Turkey, and China is a safe refuge partly because it is what these civilizations always did, how they survived, grew, and evolved into a dominating force in their respective neighborhoods. Pursuit of dominance made them averse to the universal march of liberalism and the US influence. It continues to serve as the biggest single motivator behind their increasingly concerted efforts to limit the West’s influence.

Thus, the future of the South Caucasus will be shaped by geopolitical visions, immediate goals, and the wider priorities of Iran, Turkey, Russia, and, to a certain degree, China.

This process will take place within the context of the Western need to focus its attention simultaneously on the Indo-Pacific region and the war in Ukraine. The changes will rever- berate across the South Caucasus, which has never been a foreign policy priority for the US, but nevertheless was regarded as an important juncture between East and West. The diminution of America’s interest or perhaps even influence will be proportionally substantiated by the growing position of the Eurasian powers in Western Asia and the South Caucasus in particular.

The region is and likely will continue to be plagued by the lack of coherence in the US and EU policies over governance and security issues. These are far more important than economic policies where Brussels and Washington more or less find some common ground. Both also agree on some basic elements of the South Caucasus’ importance in the regional connectivity. But the slowness with which the EU’s and NATO’s eastward expansion takes place brings about disillusionment among the political elites of the South Caucasus states (Georgia primarily).

The South Caucasus is also an increasingly fractured region. Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Georgia now have more divergent foreign policy paths than before. Some interests surely coincide, but they are tactical, more immediate in nature than long-term. Divergent foreign policy views led to radicalization of partnerships into alliances and dependencies. The process has long been in the making, but was finalized with the Second Nagorno-Karabakh War. Turkey and Russia positioned themselves as higher-status powers, while Armenia and Azerbaijan are increasingly reliant on them. Fracturing of the region is also helped by extreme securitization, when the region’s states are primarily concerned with border defense, foreign troops’ presence, and rival alliances that may harm their interests. The process is accelerating and is unlikely to subside in the near future. Securitization has also driven Georgia’s foreign policy thinking, but the country’s close ties with the EU/NATO and the US are not as cohesive as in the case of Armenia’s and Azerbaijan’s relations with their allies.

This growing fragmentation is challenging the general security and the development of infrastructure in the region. Improvement of connectivity happens only if it is supported by one of the major powers. Fragmentation also means that holistic approaches to the South Caucasus do not work.

Analysis by Emil Avdaliani

Tags: ChinaEmil AvdalianiIranRussiaSouth CaucasusTurkey
ShareShareTweet

Related Posts

Trump declares US airstrikes “obliterated” Iran’s key nuclear facilities
Highlights

Trump declares US airstrikes “obliterated” Iran’s key nuclear facilities

June 22, 2025
Iran warns U.S. has ‘crossed a red line’ after strikes on nuclear sites
International

Iran warns U.S. has ‘crossed a red line’ after strikes on nuclear sites

June 22, 2025
Prof. Michael Clarke on Putin’s Endgame: Break NATO, Dominate Europe, Cement His Legacy
Editor's Pick

Prof. Michael Clarke on Putin’s Endgame: Break NATO, Dominate Europe, Cement His Legacy

June 22, 2025

Recommended

Putin, Xi, and allied leaders mark Russia’s Victory Day at Moscow parade

Putin, Xi, and allied leaders mark Russia’s Victory Day at Moscow parade

1 month ago
Experience Seamless Connectivity with Silknet eSIM in Georgia

Experience Seamless Connectivity with Silknet eSIM in Georgia

12 months ago
Champion Karateka Luka Khvedeliani on the Benefits of Georgian Karate for Georgia’s Youth

Georgia to Celebrate First Europe Day with European Union Candidate Status

1 year ago
Georgian Foreign Minister Holds Farewell Meeting with French Ambassador to Georgia

Georgian Foreign Minister Holds Farewell Meeting with French Ambassador to Georgia

3 years ago
Natia Mezvrishvili on Dealing with 2 Political Giants

Natia Mezvrishvili on Dealing with 2 Political Giants

3 years ago
Giorgi Gakharia: We were Told We Were Capable of Nothing – It’s All a Lie and Ukraine is a Great Example of This

Giorgi Gakharia: We were Told We Were Capable of Nothing – It’s All a Lie and Ukraine is a Great Example of This

3 years ago
GT Interview with Giorgi Badridze

GT Interview with Giorgi Badridze

3 years ago
Russo-Ukrainian War and Georgia – Analysis from security expert Kakha Kemoklidze

Russo-Ukrainian War and Georgia – Analysis from security expert Kakha Kemoklidze

3 years ago

Navigation

  • News
  • Politics
  • Business & Economy
  • Social & Society
  • Sports
  • Culture
  • International
  • Where.ge
  • Newspaper
  • Magazine
  • GEO
  • OP-ED
  • About Us
    • History
    • Our Team
    • Advertising
    • Subscription
  • Contact

Highlights

Ukraine Latest: Massive Russian Attack Kills 28, Injures 134 in Kyiv

Georgian NGOs Decry ‘Russian-Style’ Data Demands from Gov’t

EU Condemns Georgia’s Media Crackdown, Demands Release of Journalist Mzia Amaglobeli

MEP Kols: I strongly demanded strict sanctions against the regime suffocating democracy in Georgia

EU Parliament urges immediate release of Amaglobeli, Devdze, Japaridze, Melia, Gvaramia & Saakashvili

Economist Khishtovani: Business climate in Georgia continues to deteriorate

Trending

Experience Seamless Connectivity with Silknet eSIM in Georgia
Business & Economy

Experience Seamless Connectivity with Silknet eSIM in Georgia

by Georgia Today
June 26, 2024

Why Silknet's eSIM could be your top choice in Georgia  Since its introduction, eSIM technology has become...

Photo by the author

Virtuosity and Versatility: Marc-André Hamelin Opens Tbilisi Piano Festival 2024

May 30, 2024
  • Where.ge
  • Newspaper
  • GEO
  • Magazine
  • Old Website

2000-2024 © Georgia Today

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business & Economy
  • Social & Society
  • Sports
  • Culture
  • International
  • Where.ge
  • Newspaper
  • Magazine
  • GEO
  • OP-ED
  • About Us
    • History
    • Our Team
    • Advertising
    • Subscription
  • Contact

2000-2024 © Georgia Today