• ABOUT US
    • History
    • Our Team
    • Advertising
    • Subscription
  • CONTACT US
Georgia Today
No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business & Economy
  • Social & Society
  • Sports
  • Culture
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business & Economy
  • Social & Society
  • Sports
  • Culture
No Result
View All Result
Georgia Today
No Result
View All Result

ECHR finds violation in Ugulava vs Georgia Case

by Georgia Today
February 2, 2024
in Highlights, Social & Society
Reading Time: 2 mins read
ECHR finds violation in Ugulava vs Georgia Case

On February 1, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) ruled that former Mayor of Tbilisi Gigi Ugulava’s right to “independent and impartial tribunal established by law” guaranteed by the Article 6 § 1 of the European Convention of Human Rights was violated by including former Prosecutor General Shalva Tadumadze on Supreme Court bench that ruled on his points-of-law appeal. The second aspect of Ugulava’s complaint regarding the lawfulness of the tribunal was rejected by the ECHR.

In 2020, the three-member chamber of the Supreme Court, consisting of former Prosecutor-General and Supreme Court judge Shalva Tadumadze, Giorgi Shavliashvili and Merab Gabinashvili found Gigi Ugulava, then one of the leaders of opposition European Georgia party guilty of misspending GEL 48 million of public money from Tbilisi Development Fund, while serving as the mayor of the capital city, and sentenced him to three years and two months in jail.

The ECHR concluded that the inclusion of former Prosecutor General of Georgia Shalva Tadumadze on Supreme Court bench that ruled on Ugulava’s points-of-law appeal was sufficient to cast doubt on “objective impartiality” of that court.

The ECHR explained that it had not been shown or argued that judge Tadumadze had held or expressed any personal convictions which could have cast doubt on his subjective impartiality, and noted that Ugulava had not submitted any evidence showing that judge Tadumadze had in fact played a dual role in the criminal proceedings against the applicant. Moreover, according to the ECtHR, the mere fact that Tadumadze was once the Prosecutor-General of Georgia was not a reason for fearing that he lacked partiality.

However, the ECHR noted that Tadumadze led Georgia’s Prosecutor’s Office when Ugulava’s case had been examined by the court of appeal in Georgia and when the decision had been made by the investigative unit at the General Prosecutor’s Office to lodge an appeal on points of law.

As the Prosecutor’s Office of Georgia appeared to the ECtHR to be a hierarchical structure with all prosecutors subordinate to Tadumadze, and to the “politically sensitive context in which the applicant’s high-profile trial had been conducted,” he must have been privy of his office’s strategy against Ugulava.

There are two aspects to the Ugulava’s Article 6 complaint. In addition to the impartiality, Ugulava had also argued to the ECtHR that judge Tadumadze had been appointed to the Supreme Court in violation of a statutory eligibility criterion. The Court rejected the complaint on the unlawfulness of the tribunal due to Ugulava’s failure to raise concerns about Tadumadze’s appointment in the appropriate domestic authority.

According to the ECHR, Ugulava waived his right to make any claim for just satisfaction.

Gigi Ugulava commented on the ECHR’s verdict, saying it “once again demonstrated that our judiciary is the oligarch’s circus.”

Tags: ECHRECHR JudgementGigi UgulavaUgulava vs Georgia Case
ShareShareTweet

Related Posts

Court replaces Nika Melia’s bail with detention over commission no-show
Highlights

Court replaces Nika Melia’s bail with detention over commission no-show

May 30, 2025
Irakli Kobakhidze discusses US ties and regional stability with senator Steve Daines
Highlights

Irakli Kobakhidze discusses US ties and regional stability with senator Steve Daines

May 30, 2025
“Ukraine Has No Choice But to Fight”: Shekhovtsov on Why Surrender Means National Erasure
Editor's Pick

“Ukraine Has No Choice But to Fight”: Shekhovtsov on Why Surrender Means National Erasure

May 30, 2025

Recommended

Putin, Xi, and allied leaders mark Russia’s Victory Day at Moscow parade

Putin, Xi, and allied leaders mark Russia’s Victory Day at Moscow parade

3 weeks ago
Experience Seamless Connectivity with Silknet eSIM in Georgia

Experience Seamless Connectivity with Silknet eSIM in Georgia

11 months ago
Champion Karateka Luka Khvedeliani on the Benefits of Georgian Karate for Georgia’s Youth

Georgia to Celebrate First Europe Day with European Union Candidate Status

1 year ago
Georgian Foreign Minister Holds Farewell Meeting with French Ambassador to Georgia

Georgian Foreign Minister Holds Farewell Meeting with French Ambassador to Georgia

3 years ago
Natia Mezvrishvili on Dealing with 2 Political Giants

Natia Mezvrishvili on Dealing with 2 Political Giants

3 years ago
Giorgi Gakharia: We were Told We Were Capable of Nothing – It’s All a Lie and Ukraine is a Great Example of This

Giorgi Gakharia: We were Told We Were Capable of Nothing – It’s All a Lie and Ukraine is a Great Example of This

3 years ago
GT Interview with Giorgi Badridze

GT Interview with Giorgi Badridze

3 years ago
Russo-Ukrainian War and Georgia – Analysis from security expert Kakha Kemoklidze

Russo-Ukrainian War and Georgia – Analysis from security expert Kakha Kemoklidze

3 years ago

Navigation

  • News
  • Politics
  • Business & Economy
  • Social & Society
  • Sports
  • Culture
  • International
  • Where.ge
  • Newspaper
  • Magazine
  • GEO
  • OP-ED
  • About Us
    • History
    • Our Team
    • Advertising
    • Subscription
  • Contact

Highlights

MIA: Nika Melia detained on administrative charges

Ukraine Latest: Drones, Drills, and Diplomacy

British Journalist Barred from Georgia after Investigating Links to Sanctioned Russian Oligarch

The Blooming Electric Now: How DOCA Film Club’s ‘New Georgian Films’ Program Captures a Nation Mid-Transformation

ZEG Festival returns to Tbilisi with future-focused storytelling

Giorgi Bachiashvili: Ivanishvili’s orders led to my kidnapping and 2 days blindfolded

Trending

Experience Seamless Connectivity with Silknet eSIM in Georgia
Business & Economy

Experience Seamless Connectivity with Silknet eSIM in Georgia

by Georgia Today
June 26, 2024

Why Silknet's eSIM could be your top choice in Georgia  Since its introduction, eSIM technology has become...

Photo by the author

Virtuosity and Versatility: Marc-André Hamelin Opens Tbilisi Piano Festival 2024

May 30, 2024
  • Where.ge
  • Newspaper
  • GEO
  • Magazine
  • Old Website

2000-2024 © Georgia Today

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business & Economy
  • Social & Society
  • Sports
  • Culture
  • International
  • Where.ge
  • Newspaper
  • Magazine
  • GEO
  • OP-ED
  • About Us
    • History
    • Our Team
    • Advertising
    • Subscription
  • Contact

2000-2024 © Georgia Today