• ABOUT US
    • History
    • Our Team
    • Advertising
    • Subscription
  • CONTACT US
Georgia Today
No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business & Economy
  • Social & Society
  • Sports
  • Culture
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business & Economy
  • Social & Society
  • Sports
  • Culture
No Result
View All Result
Georgia Today
No Result
View All Result

The Age of Counter-Enlightenment

by Georgia Today
April 28, 2022
in Analysis, Editor's Pick, Newspaper, Politics
Reading Time: 3 mins read
Putin and Biden: Biden’s insistence on upholding democratic and liberal ideals suggests the US is willing to battle illiberalism. By Saul Loeb/Pool via REUTERS

Putin and Biden: Biden’s insistence on upholding democratic and liberal ideals suggests the US is willing to battle illiberalism. By Saul Loeb/Pool via REUTERS

We live in the age of counter-Enlightenment. What seemed like a collection of dispersed autocratic and simply illiberal states, has now coalesced into a fully blown ideological movement premised on not only resisting liberal internationalism on an ad hoc basis, but exporting authoritarian models of governance.

Illiberalism’s flag-bearers in China and Russia have also shown they can harness modernity. What was deemed an asset peculiar to the West, because progress was considered a direct result of liberal norms and vice versa, is now being fitfully mastered by its enemies.

Yet, the bad news comes with a good-news rider. If the United States wants to maintain global influence, it cannot simply seek to maintain the old world order. The appearance of serious rivals with a hostile ideology will stiffen America’s resolve. This happened in the Second World War and in the Cold War. For the past decade or more, this ideological motivation has been lacking because China’s competition was mostly still viewed as fitting within the framework of the liberal world order. China, the West wrongly believed, could be lured into better behavior by the self-evident benefits of cooperation.

Take China and Russia. Westerners expected poor economic conditions to liberalize or even bring down those regimes, but the reality is quite different. China gathered strength after the 2008 financial crisis and raised its profile through vaccine diplomacy during the Covid-19 pandemic. Russia, despite suffering from extensive sanctions, is growing more assertive in the South Caucasus, Black Sea and parts of the Middle East. Even in Iran’s case, its most active foreign involvement coincided with the Western sanctions.
Illiberalism has been wrongly described as unstable and as a transitory stage in the evolution towards the liberal-democratic model. But armed with the trappings of modern technology, it is resilient and resourceful, and is a much longer-term challenge than the crude communism of the past. Failure to deliver on its promises ultimately killed the communist dream, but failure to deliver in quasi-capitalist illiberal states will not bring down the order as quickly as some would think.

The West should support the fragile states of Georgia, Ukraine, Moldova and Armenia because there is still some hope they can take a better path

China and Russia’s example makes illiberalism fashionable among the struggling states of Europe and Asia. In Georgia, Far-Right movements repudiate the tenets of liberalism and advocate the reversal of the entire political system, and, what is more important, seek closer ties with Russia. Their arguments are more nuanced though. Fearing a backlash, they explain the need to work with Russia as a geopolitical necessity.

All these problems are abetted by Russia’s military presence on their sovereign territory and by troubled economies which create space for China’s powerful economy. The governments in these once Soviet states are manifesting the ability to appropriate the liberal concepts on state and economy to advance their illiberal agenda.

The West has to look at this challenge from a wider historical perspective. Hopes for the eventual abandonment of the illiberal governing model are not as self-fulfilling. Bolstering the liberal order by strengthening rules-based policies is one approach. Another is to show that liberalism is more attuned to the economic and governance progress. The means to shore up state institutions in those fragile countries should be sought.

The West should support the fragile states of Georgia, Ukraine, Moldova and Armenia because there is still some hope they can take a better path. Recently, Georgia’s politicians resolved a major political crisis by re-entering the legislature after months of boycotts. In Armenia, the decision to call snap parliamentary elections lowered political tensions. Illiberalism in the region, all Armenia’s and Georgia’s neighbors are less-than-liberal states, could easily engulf these tiny islands of aspiring democracy.

Illiberalism is essentially a counter-Enlightenment and is seen by autocrats as a return to normalcy in human and state relations. They hail the primacy of state and strongman rule or clique rule and create something eerily reminiscent of illiberal governments between the two world wars, when democracy could not survive pressures from within and without.

Biden’s insistence on upholding democratic and liberal ideals suggests the US is willing to battle illiberalism. Whichever model prevails will ultimately define the world we live in and will be decisive for smaller states bordering illiberal powers. Military power matters, but the battle for hearts and minds is just as important.

Analysis by Emil Avdaliani

Emil Avdaliani is professor at European University and the director of Middle East Studies at Georgian think tank, Geocase.

Tags: ChinaEmil AvdalianiilliberalismRussia
ShareShareTweet

Related Posts

Nationwide Rehabilitation and Construction Planned for 885 Kindergartens
News

Nationwide Rehabilitation and Construction Planned for 885 Kindergartens

January 30, 2023
Levan Khabeishvili Voted in as UNM Chairman
News

Levan Khabeishvili Voted in as UNM Chairman

January 30, 2023
Police in Gudauri near the popular ski lifts. Photo from the Ministry of Internal Affairs
Newspaper

Trouble in Gudauri: “Mafia” Opposes Foreign Workforce

January 28, 2023

Recommended

Georgian Foreign Minister Holds Farewell Meeting with French Ambassador to Georgia

Georgian Foreign Minister Holds Farewell Meeting with French Ambassador to Georgia

4 months ago
Natia Mezvrishvili on Dealing with 2 Political Giants

Natia Mezvrishvili on Dealing with 2 Political Giants

10 months ago
Giorgi Gakharia: We were Told We Were Capable of Nothing – It’s All a Lie and Ukraine is a Great Example of This

Giorgi Gakharia: We were Told We Were Capable of Nothing – It’s All a Lie and Ukraine is a Great Example of This

11 months ago
GT Interview with Giorgi Badridze

GT Interview with Giorgi Badridze

11 months ago
Russo-Ukrainian War and Georgia – Analysis from security expert Kakha Kemoklidze

Russo-Ukrainian War and Georgia – Analysis from security expert Kakha Kemoklidze

11 months ago

Navigation

  • News
  • Politics
  • Business & Economy
  • Social & Society
  • Sports
  • Culture
  • International
  • Where.ge
  • Newspaper
  • Magazine
  • GEO
  • OP-ED
  • About Us
    • History
    • Our Team
    • Advertising
    • Subscription
  • Contact

Highlights

EU, Georgia Hold 5th Strategic Security Dialogue

Ukraine’s Chargé d’Affaires Suggests Ukrainians be Evacuated from Georgia

Administration: President’s Words Being Systematically Distorted, Misleading Public

Eight Countries Join Tightened EU Sanctions against Russia

Kharkiv Mayor, Lviv Governor Send Thank-you Letter to Georgian FM

Carl Bildt: Refusal of Regime to Allow Saakashvili Proper Treatment Abroad Truly Shameful

Trending

No Content Available
  • Where.ge
  • Newspaper
  • GEO
  • Magazine
  • Old Website

2000-2022 © Georgia Today

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business & Economy
  • Social & Society
  • Sports
  • Culture
  • International
  • Where.ge
  • Newspaper
  • Magazine
  • GEO
  • OP-ED
  • About Us
    • History
    • Our Team
    • Advertising
    • Subscription
  • Contact

2000-2022 © Georgia Today